Justice Katju: The Supreme Court That Never Adjourned (Now Sitting Permanently on X- Twitter)

Justice Markandey Katju
Justice Markandey Katju

There are retired judges who take up arbitration, write memoirs, or finally learn to relax. And then there is Justice Markandey Katju, who apparently decided that retirement was just a change of venue from the Supreme Court to the court of public opinion, where he continues to deliver bold, unfiltered, and frequently viral judgments on politics, society, beauty, and basically everything else that crosses his timeline.

In a country where most public figures measure every word like it’s evidence, Katju operates on a different principle: say it first, clarify that it was a joke later, and if people still don’t get it, remind them that 90% of Indians are fools anyway. The result is pure entertainment — equal parts constitutional law, Urdu sher, and that one uncle at every wedding who has strong opinions on everything from democracy to who should wink at whom.

The Political Bench: Where Everyone Is Guilty

On politics, Justice Katju has achieved something rare: he is disliked by almost every side with remarkable consistency. Congress, BJP, regional parties — according to him, they are all more or less worthless experts in polarising people on caste and religion so they can stay in power. Democracy, in his view, is not some sacred holy cow but a system that, as actually practised in India, further entrenches the very feudal forces (casteism and communalism) that are holding the country back. He has called it a “fetish” more than once.

Recently, when the opposition was busy organising rallies against alleged “vote chori,” Katju essentially shrugged and said the whole exercise misses the point. Whether there is vote theft or not, he argued, the lives of ordinary people won’t dramatically improve just by changing which set of politicians is in charge. He even described Rahul Gandhi, with characteristic bluntness, as a “mad wannabe king” who seems to believe the Nehru-Gandhi family has a divine right to rule forever. The mock parliament idea and the Ramlila Ground rally plans received the full Katju treatment — historical comparisons included.

He isn’t pro-anyone in the current setup. His preferred future involves modern-minded leaders (he has mentioned the Mustafa Kemal model before) who can actually transform India into a strong industrial power, rather than the present lot who, in his estimation, specialise in keeping people divided. Whether you agree or not, the man does not hedge.

Social Media: Where Jokes Go to Become Controversies

Katju’s online style is legendary. He posts long, essay-like threads, sprinkles in poetry, and then drops lines that make half the internet gasp. His defence is almost always the same: it was said in lighter vein, but 90% of Indians lack a sense of humour and take everything literally.

The classic examples still get retold. There was the suggestion that if Pakistan wants Kashmir, India should offer it on the condition that they also take Bihar. Demonstrations followed, posters were blackened, and a sedition case was filed. Then there was the question of why Bengalis couldn’t find a good husband for Mamata Banerjee. A TMC leader reportedly offered to slap him if he visited Kolkata. On both occasions, Katju explained that any person with common sense would have understood it was a joke. The problem, as he sees it, is that common sense is in short supply.

His general advice to Indians is therefore simple and deeply Katju-esque: never joke in public. Keep a funereal, sullen, humourless expression at all times, otherwise someone whose feelings have been hurt will file a case.

Interactions with Ladies: Peak Katju

This is where the entertainment value peaks. Justice Katju has never been shy about commenting on women, beauty, marriage, or courtroom dynamics. His advice to young men has included the practical tip that nature matters more than looks — beautiful women with terrible natures exist, and so do plain-looking women who make life heavenly. Check character, he says, before you check the mirror.

More recently came the episode that temporarily broke the internet: when a lady lawyer asked for tips on effective courtroom arguments, he replied (in lighter vein, of course) that she should wink at the judge, adding that the lady lawyers who had winked at him in court got favourable orders. The post was deleted after outrage from lawyers’ associations. He later apologised, explaining it was a joke that “90% of Indians” failed to understand. He followed it up with a longer note listing the things he had actually done for women lawyers during his judicial career (building facilities, setting up a creche, etc.), essentially arguing that he is the opposite of a misogynist.

Even as recently as this week, he posted the classic line: “Woh kambakht hai jo kisi ladki ko badsoorat kahe” — he is a scoundrel who calls a girl ugly. Whether this is philosophy, poetry, or just Katju being Katju, it fits the pattern perfectly.

He has also written about encounters with young ladies at parties (one short in height, another obsessing over weight) and recalled a meeting with a beautiful film actress when he was Chief Justice of Madras High Court, which he handled carefully so as not to get a certain kind of reputation.

The Verdict

Love him, roll your eyes at him, or both at the same time, Justice Katju has become one of the most consistent sources of unscripted commentary in Indian public life. He still writes like a judge delivering a judgment, argues like a lawyer, and jokes like an uncle who refuses to read the room. In an age of carefully managed PR and calculated silence, he remains gloriously, chaotically outspoken.

The man never really left the bench. He simply moved it to X, where court is always in session, the judgments are free, and the only permanent order is that most of us still don’t get the joke.

Related Post