Legal News and Insight around the Globe!

Trump, Xi and Putin Talk UN Reform: What India Can Actually Extract from the Moment

LI Network

When Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin sat down in Shenzhen on 19 November and put their names to a short declaration calling for the United Nations to be reformed so it can “respond more effectively to global challenges,” the Indian reaction was almost automatic. New Delhi has been asking for a permanent seat on the Security Council for more than thirty years. Any joint statement from three of the five permanent members that even mentions reform is bound to be read through that lens.

The document itself is careful. It commits the three countries, “as permanent members,” to making the UN better at its core job of maintaining international peace and security. It says nothing about enlarging the Council, nothing about new permanent seats, and nothing about India by name. Putin later told reporters that the three leaders had discussed “the possibility of reforming and increasing the potential of the United Nations” and the need to adapt it to today’s realities. That is as far as the public record goes.

Still, the fact that the three leaders chose to put UN reform on the table at all creates a narrow opening that Indian diplomacy can try to use. The question is not whether the Shenzhen meeting suddenly hands New Delhi a permanent seat. It is what practical gains India can still pursue while the larger question of Charter amendment remains frozen.

India’s case is well known and, on the merits, difficult to dismiss. It is a founding member of the UN, the world’s most populous country, a major economy, a functioning democracy, and one of the largest contributors of troops to UN peacekeeping. External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar has repeatedly said that keeping such a country out of the Council’s permanent membership is not only unfair to India but also damages the credibility of the Council itself. The G4 (India, Brazil, Germany and Japan) continues to press for expansion in both permanent and non-permanent categories, and the same argument is made through the IBSA grouping with Brazil and South Africa.

The procedural obstacles have not changed. Any real expansion requires an amendment to the UN Charter under Article 108. That needs a two-thirds majority in the General Assembly and subsequent ratification by two-thirds of member states, including all five existing permanent members. Each of the P5 therefore holds an effective veto over the entire process. China has long said it supports reform that improves representation of developing countries, especially African ones, while remaining carefully non-committal on India’s individual claim. Pakistan, though not a permanent member, remains an active member of the Uniting for Consensus group that opposes any new permanent seats.

In this environment, the most realistic near-term gains for India lie outside the binary of “permanent seat or nothing.”

First, India can use the public acknowledgement by three P5 members that the UN needs reform to keep the issue alive in every available forum the Intergovernmental Negotiations in New York, the G4 meetings, and the L.69 grouping of developing countries that want a more representative Council. Even if the Shenzhen declaration was largely rhetorical, it gives Indian diplomats a fresh hook when they argue that the status quo is no longer sustainable even in the eyes of some permanent members.

Second, India can press for concrete improvements in the Council’s working methods that do not require Charter amendment. Greater transparency in how the P5 negotiate, more meaningful consultation with troop-contributing countries, and clearer rules on the use of the veto on certain categories of issues are all areas where progress is possible without enlarging the Council. These changes would not give India a permanent seat, but they would increase the practical influence of countries that contribute most to the UN’s work.

Third, India can continue to build the broader political majority that any future amendment will need. Support from African countries, Latin American states and other parts of the Global South is already substantial. The Shenzhen moment can be used to remind these partners that three of the permanent members have at least accepted the principle of reform, and that the remaining resistance should not be allowed to freeze the conversation indefinitely.

Finally, India can treat the permanent-seat question as a long-term objective while extracting value from the platforms it already has. Its recent and upcoming non-permanent terms, its leadership in peacekeeping, and its growing economic weight already give it more voice than many formal permanent members on certain issues. Strengthening that practical role — in climate security, counter-terrorism, or the regulation of new technologies builds the very legitimacy that makes the case for permanent membership harder to ignore over time.

None of this guarantees a permanent seat in the foreseeable future. The incentives of the current permanent members to dilute their own power remain weak, and China-Pakistan opposition is structural. But the Shenzhen declaration at least confirms that the idea of an unreformed UN is becoming politically awkward even for some of the countries that benefit most from the present arrangement. India’s task is to convert that awkwardness into sustained diplomatic pressure, incremental institutional improvements, and a steadily widening coalition, rather than waiting for a single dramatic breakthrough that the existing power structure is designed to prevent.